Black Sheep Coal-Fired Pizza

Reviews

• 

  G Wat 11 months ago

  5.0

  Very cool spot! Had great reviews so stopped in for dinner with the family. We had the cheesy bread with marinara which was good. We also ordered the grilled vegetables appetizer that we enjoyed. Then my wife and daughter ordered a pizza with tomatoes, feta cheese, harissa and fennel sausage which they really enjoyed. My son is a basic pizza kid so we split a pepperoni pizza which we also enjoyed. We all liked the coal fired approach which reminded us of some of the places we enjoyed when we lived in CT (New Haven). Service is going to get its own section here in the write up because it was exceptional! We had an Asian guy (apologies I can't recall his name) who took care of us who was fantastic! Positive attitude, super upbeat and friendly. Very helpful with menu suggestions and beer suggestions as well. Very attentive, refills were timely, never had any long stretches where he disappeared (and they were PACKED). Really stayed on top of everything and provided a great experience overall. Excellent meal and experience and I highly recommend you give it a shot if you're in the area.

  via
• 

  Brian Curry 5 months ago

  5.0

  Our server was amazing. We had 14 people on a Saturday and she was on top of it. Great food and loved it had Christmas decorations!

  via
• 

  H. Freckles 5 months ago

  5.0

  Attentive staff and excellent service. We got the hot salami pizza and it was good though not hot enough in my personal opinion. They have root beer on tap that is delicious and decent beer. We’ll be back to try more pizza!

  via
• 

  Braydi McPherson 11 months ago

  5.0

  I was visiting for a work trip and someone from Chicago told me I had to try this pizza on my way in on the Amtrak. The pizza was so good!! They even let you do half and half pizzas, so you can try more of their delicious flavors. I went with the meatball/ricotta (#4) and the smoked chicken (#14), and it was one of the best pizzas I’ve had. The crust was perfectly crispy and the flavors were freak and complex. The service was phenomenal and they made sure my water never got below half full on a hot day in the city. I did pay $3/hr for parking, but that’s to be expected anywhere in the city. If you like quality pizza from a local company that supports their workers, this is a must try spot.

  via
• 

  Joe Reno 4 months ago

  5.0

  Service was prompt and tentative. Pizza came out and was cooked perfectly. Crispy bottom with just enough flop to it. Ordered a simple pepperoni. Sauce is light and refreshing. Cheese had very good flavor. Pepperoni were on the mild side but worked well with all the flavors. The crust had nice spots of char without being over cooked.

  via
• R

  R57NMmikeb 11 months ago

  5.0

  Excellent Pizza. Crispy crust, good char. My daughter had a gluten free crust. She felt it was the best gluten free pizza she has had in the past 3 years of going GF.

  via
• 7

  725kenq 2 years ago

  5.0

  Fantastic pizza, fantastic atmosphere, fantastic staff. They were so nice. The food and drinks came really fast. It was a great experience. I highly recommend this place

  via
• 3

  33christosh 2 years ago

  1.0

  Do not go here! This is the worst experience I have had at any restaurant in a long time. They literally forgot my pizza while my family eas eating. Just don't bother with this place

  via
• L

  lori1019 4 years ago

  5.0

  We enjoyed sitting outside and sharing pizzas. The service was great and the price was reasonable. The pizzas were very good, not outstanding or different, but tasty for the price.

  via