Nancy's Pizzeria

Reviews

• 

  Antoine Shelton 3 months ago

  5.0

  I’ll be honest—I’m usually the person skipping the BBQ sauce entirely. But Nancy’s Pizza has officially changed the game for me. Their house BBQ sauce is absolutely superb; it’s so well-balanced that it won over someone who doesn't even like BBQ sauce. We tried both the BBQ Chicken Pizza and the BBQ Hawaiian Pizza, and both were incredible. The flavors are bold, the crust is exactly what you want from a Chicago staple, and that house sauce really ties everything together. The Highlights: • The Caesar Salad: Do not sleep on this! We added anchovies, and it was excellent—fresh, salty, and the perfect punchy side to the pizza. • The Service: The servers were extremely nice. The customer service was top-tier from start to finish, which really elevated the whole experience. The only slight miss for us were the Buffalo wings, which were a bit mediocre compared to the high bar set by the rest of the meal. However, the pizza and salad more than made up for it. If you’re in Chicago, Nancy’s is a must-visit. Even if you think you don't like BBQ sauce, give theirs a try—you’ll be surprised!

  via
• 

  Erynn Schroeder 3 months ago

  5.0

  The BEST restaurant week deal I’ve come across. For $60 for 2 people, you get drinks (signature cocktail, beer, wine, or soda) an appetizer, salad, pizza and two cannolis. Easily could’ve had a third person for this meal. Nancy’s stuffed pizza was the highlight!

  via
• 

  Flower 2 months ago

  5.0

  Came here on a Monday evening for dinner and we had the hot buffalo chicken pizza and it was delicious. Unfortunately, we were so hungry and excited for the pizza we started eating before I remembered to take a pic. But trust it was delicious.

  via
• 

  Mariah Kamara (Naomi) 4 months ago

  5.0

  Nancy’s Pizza has never disappointed me and I have been getting their pizza for years. The other night I was completely baked and my munchies were in full effect. I couldn’t decide whether to wait for delivery like a responsible adult or just grab my pizza and go. I live just a few blocks away so I went with pick-up and ordered a super thin 12" pizza with Italian sausage and mushrooms to enjoy myself and share a little with my dog Winston. Picking up the pizza was smooth as always. The staff was friendly and welcoming and the restaurant is always clean and organized. Every single time I have picked up an order it has been ready exactly when they said it would be which makes life so much easier. Taking the pizza home was the best part. Every bite was amazing. The crust, the toppings, and the balance of flavors were perfect. Eating it baked at home felt like pure bliss. Honestly Nancy’s is one of the best pizza spots in Chicago and I don’t see that changing anytime soon. Nancy’s I will absolutely be back. You have a loyal fan in me and Winston is already plotting the next slice.

  via
• 

  Gene Notto 2 months ago

  5.0

  This is a great version of Chicago style stuffed or Deep-dish pizza. There is not too much crust, the sauce is great; a good amount of cheese(not too much and not too little!). I really like this pizza. This is a perfect stop when in the West Loop neighborhood.

  via
• G

  gwardbeeler 5 months ago

  5.0

  We wanted to try Chicago style pizza. Nancy’s was yummy. Service was friendly and the atmosphere was casual. There were 5 of us in our party. We ordered a medium Chicago style with pepperoni thick crust pizza and a small Rocco’s Party rustic crust pizza, one large salad and Brussel sprouts. There was plenty of pizza to go around and some left over. The thick crust was so rich and loaded with cheese. Yummy! We enjoyed our meal and would highly recommend Nancy’s.

  via
• D

  Duoadrift 8 months ago

  4.0

  Solid pepperoni, mushroom and mozzarella cheese pizza pie, ordered and received extra crispy. Began with a mixed green and Caesar salad – both as fresh as could be and plentiful. Super clean restaurant, cool décor, great location and decent beers on tap and wine available. Really struggled with this not being a '5', and I can only point to crust texture (Like a cracker / bread crust) being one deviation outside our preferred norm, some likely love it, just unconventional for us. Shout out to Linsey who took great care of us.

  via
• S

  strommie 11 months ago

  5.0

  The food is very good and fresh. I had the thin crust pizza and my husband had the Italian beef. We will be back!!!!!!!!!!!

  via
• I

  INM30 1 year ago

  4.0

  For Chicago style crespy pizza this is the prefect restaurant to try it tasty delicious the secret in the cheese love it, also tried the garlic cheesy bread, I recommend to ask for sharp knifes to cut pizza and big diffrent eating pizza directly from oven than delivered to you so if it your first time dine in to feel more taste.

  via
• A

  Ansedonia411 1 year ago

  4.0

  Excellent deep dish and gluten-free pizza at reasonable prices. I wish they had a more extensive wine list. The green salad and the Caesar salad were excellent; fun for all.

  via