Made in New York Pizza

Reviews

• M

  manhattanchickie2020 3 months ago

  1.0

  Overpriced, cracker-like hard crust, tasteless sauce, and over-cooked pizza. The staff are rude, have zero positive energy. Even though they made the pizzeria larger, the pizza is still incredibly mediocre.

  via
• T

  T6596JHchriss 1 year ago

  3.0

  This was the best pizza I had in New York. The sauce was the right about of thick and salty. The cheese was textured well and also flavorful. The dough was soft, chewy and thin in the right places. And the staff apparently knew it. The guy at the register the night we ate there was a straight up jerk. Not in the “I’m in a hurry, please do this quickly” way that is pretty typical of everyone we encountered. It’s a vibe and I’m fine with it. This guy charged us for food and when we asked about it, he gave us a blank stare as though we were idiots. The other guys who were busting their butts and this guy did not seem to communicate well with one another, which was just weird. Anyways, it was worth it, so whatever!

  via
• T

  TedDR5 1 year ago

  1.0

  Ordered a "new margherita" for delivery from West Village location. Photo shows rich tomato sauce, cheese, and many fresh basil leaves. Reality: a cracker-like crust, dry and thin, a thin wash of tomato sauce, and not a single fresh basil leaf. Bore no resemblance to a true margherita. I have eaten far better frozen pizza baked at home--literally. To top it off, it was delivered cold. Trying, and failing, to imagine how could have been worse.

  via
• L

  Lorimendenhall 1 year ago

  5.0

  great spot on the UWS! I was skeptical - dumb name and it didn't look like anything was piping fresh out of the oven. but the reviews were great and we were in the area after visiting NY Historical Society. The square with eggplant was amazing - tangy sauce, crust with a little crunch, eggplant that was easy to bite, and just the right amount of cheese. I will get this again for sure. It was $5.50 or $6 per piece. I also go a regular plain which was above average but nothing significantly special. All the pizza is sitting out and they reheat what you select. they did NOT make our food piping hot but it tasted so good I didn't even bother to complain. they have a lot of compelling choices. it's obviously popular because it got really busy after we sat down (around 2:30). I saw a few other locations that looked like they have the same food but I went to this one on 80th and Amsterdam.

  via