Luigi's Pizza
4.5

Luigi's Pizza

686 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, Brooklyn, United States

€€€€ #10 of 44 in Brooklyn

Services & facilities

Dine-inTakeaway
Pizza Lovers say: "Authentic NY pizza atmosphere and gold standard pizza. Slices were so-so, sauce and cheese didn't stand out."

Reviews

4.5 Good
Based on 2,571 reviews across Google and TripAdvisor
  • 5 2,049
  • 4 249
  • 3 99
  • 2 49
  • 1 125
  • George Marneris 2 months ago
    5.0
    Luigi’s is the epitome of what a classic NY pizzeria is! Old school authentic pizza atmosphere. Their pizza is the gold standard and defines traditional NY pizza. They set the bar high. Family owned and run, focusing on great quality …
  • George Marneris
  • carlos borges 3 weeks ago
    4.0
    I absolutely love the vibe of this place, but the slices I had were just so-so. I tried both the plain slice and the square, and unfortunately, both fell short on flavor. Neither the sauce nor the cheese really stood out. The flavor profile …
  • Mike A. a month ago
    5.0
    Reviewing Luigi’s Pizza is difficult because it’s more than just a pizzeria to me—it’s a place filled with some of my favorite childhood memories. …
  • E2001JVgarym
    5.0
    Warm, authentic, and unforgettable. I had a fantastic experience at Luigi’s. Gio and his family treat you like you’re one of their own from the moment you walk in. The pizza was outstanding, truly some of the best I’ve had in Brooklyn. What made the evening even more special was the hospitality. Gio’s sister invited me back to the kitchen, where we sampled their fresh sauce, homemade sausage, and bread right out of the oven. What stayed with me most was hearing Gio speak about his father, Luigi, with such love and affection. It’s clear he’s carrying on a family tradition with real pride. This place isn’t just a restaurant, it’s a labor of love and a legacy being honored every day. It felt less like dining out and more like being welcomed into a family home. Highly recommend.
  • alejandramercedesj
    4.0
    A very tiny place for a great pizza experience. You can see the owner making the pizzas himself. Magic. There are only a few small tables at the back, so be ready to have to wait. It's worth it.
  • kiwiflyer10
    5.0
    We went a long way out of our way to go to Luigi’s and we certainly weren’t disappointed. The pizza was delicious. Even got to meet Geo himself. Definitely recommend a visit. They are increasing the size of the store which will hopefully mean more space to eat in.
  • B3641EWjackf
    5.0
    The most amazing pizza we have ever tasted in our lives! It was our first New York pizza and we did not find anywhere that came close to it.
  • francoq685
    5.0
    Old School pizzeria in Brooklyn NY. Only the highest quality ingredients are used here. Pizzas are flavorful and made fresh daily! Gio the owner is very hospitable and appreciates his customers very much! Easy to reach from Manhattan by train. Short walk from the station in a great neighborhood. Enjoy!

Other ratings

More pizza in Brooklyn

See all pizza in Brooklyn