Pugsley Pizza

Reviews

• 8

  849elyf 2 months ago

  3.0

  After all the hype around Joe’s Pizza, my Tati and I finally decided to see what the talk was about. First off, the line was no joke—wrapped around the block when we first arrived. We came back later and it was much more manageable, and while waiting we actually met some really cool people. So the experience started off solid. We ordered the White Pizza and a Fresh Mozzarella slice. I’m gonna keep it all the way honest—it was good, fresh, and definitely made right, but it didn’t hit the way the hype suggested it would. In NYC terms… it was a little mid for me. Not bad at all, just not memorable enough to justify that kind of wait. I understand the thin crust, classic New York style thing—that part is respected—but for my taste it felt a bit too thin and was missing that extra flavor punch that makes you go “yeah, I get it now.” It just didn’t quite reach that level. Overall, I’m glad I tried it. It’s part of the NYC pizza experience and I can respect the history and the crowd it draws. But keeping it real, it’s more of a “try it once” spot for me rather than somewhere I’d line up for again. 3 stars feels fair: good, not great, definitely hyped higher than it delivers in my opinion. Still worth the experience though—you gotta see it for yourself.

  via
• I

  ileanadp 2 months ago

  5.0

  Love this place and I will always love it! The pizza is tue best pizza I ever tried, and the service is good.

  via
• B

  boomkyker 2 months ago

  1.0

  Do not bother standing in line because it is NOT worth it.The choice is limited and the slices are like dry biscuit with the toppings that will make a pizza lover cry. Service friendly but the tasteless piece of dry crust is a tourist trap .

  via
• L

  LM4ev 2 months ago

  5.0

  Totally worth the hype !!!!! The line ups at this place just didn’t end but well worth the wait!!!

  via