Paulie's Pizza

Reviews

• V

  Valentina Bonomi 2 months ago

  5.0

  I honestly don't understand the bad reviews. I went for takeout and asked for the 4 slices combo so I got one of each flavor. ALL OF THEM WERE AMAZING! If you like the NYC slice style, you won't be disappointed by this pizza. 29 for 4 …

  via
• C

  Carlito 3 months ago

  5.0

  Hip hop vibes and good pizza. Nuff said. Had the mushroom work stracciatella and the basic Margherita. Excellent. Good value and open when you need a slice on Oxford.

  via
• S

  Seth Barbarona 2 months ago

  5.0

  It was a bit late at night and we were craving pizza, so we decided to try Paulie's, and we definitely didn't regret it! The staff were warm and welcoming, and the pizzas were delicious with plenty of options to choose from. We had a great experience and would happily come back.

  via
• A

  Ange P 3 months ago

  5.0

  Service was super friendly, atmosphere was great, interior design was done really well. The pizza flavours were super tasty, had a great base which was not too thick not too thin and wasn’t soggy or anything. It had a nice crisp to it. The

  via
• J

  J D 2 months ago

  5.0

  The pepperoni pizza was excellent. I was most impressed by how perfectly crispy the crust was — it had the ideal crunch while still being light. Great flavour, quality ingredients, and I'll definitely be back.

  via
• C

  Claire Tan 3 months ago

  5.0

  Love their thin crust NY style pizza especially the spicy vodka and the white slice. It's a pity we came too early and the specials ain't available. We will be back for more

  via
• I

  Isabella 3 months ago

  5.0

  never tried new york pizza before and this may be the closest thing i have and it was DELICIOUS 🤤 recommend their tiramisu as well 👍 hands down can’t choose a fav because every slice was yummy as heck and they’re all so different from each other and paired together with the hot honey WOW

  via
• A

  Alexa Homchick a month ago

  5.0

  Such a great new spot! As Americans, we loved how the cool fit-out reminded us of being in New York. The pizza was so good — the Sicilian-style and white slice were definitely our favorites. The staff were also so nice and welcoming. Such a fun addition to Sydney, we’ll definitely be back!

  via
• C

  Charbel Zeaiter (Charbel.J.Z) 4 weeks ago

  2.0

  Friendly service. Ordered the pepperoni square pizza slice. First time in my life I couldn't finish a pizza slice im afraid. Surprisingly disappointed. Bland with hardly any sauce which lead to a very dry slice... not

  via