Arturo's Coal Oven Pizza

Reviews

• M

  Mrs. Potsy Oct 2025

  4.0

  Cozy booths and intimate bar, meatball sliders with flavorful fillings and fresh ingredients with good char on the crust. A real Greenwich Village gem.

  via
• R

  Rachel C Mar 2025

  1.0

  Long-time customer. Very disappointed with staff rudeness regarding seating and the manager's dismissive attitude toward complaints about poor treatment. Will not return.

  via
• J

  Joseph M Dec 2024

  5.0

  Great pizza in an old school setting. Dark, crowded, loud atmosphere with live music. This place has been a fixture since the 1950s and still delivers.

  via
• S

  StandingXander Jan 2025

  3.0

  Food was unexceptional and quite bland. I think one can do a lot better for this price point in New York City.

  via
• M

  Michael S May 2024

  5.0

  Returned three times during my visit. The crispy crust and anchovy pizzas were excellent — that coal oven reaches 1000°F and you can taste the difference.

  via