Seppe Pizza Bar

Reviews

• 

  Ariana Martinez 4 months ago

  5.0

  Absolutely amazing experience! My partner and I stopped in on a cold Sunday, not feeling our best and dressed in our lazy clothes but when the pizza craving hits, it hits. We’ve tried all the NYC classics like Joe’s and John’s, discovered hidden gems, and even traveled upstate in search of great pizza. Hands down, the best pizza we’ve had in Manhattan so far is Seppe. We had the pleasure of speaking with the manager, Noah, who let us know they also have a Staten Island location definitely adding that to our list. If you get the chance, don’t walk to this place run. Our favorites were the Aunt Honey pizza and the special vodka sauce pizza… unreal. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the hospitality is truly top notch. They do an incredible job making sure your experience is memorable it genuinely feels like visiting family. We can’t wait to come back! 🍕✨

  via
• 

  Zerlina Lin 4 months ago

  4.0

  Came on. Sunday Aunt Honey (Soppressata, chili flakes hot honey)- while the pizza is delicious for a standard pizza. I wish it had more hot honey flavor as that was supposed to be one of the topping Brussel sprouts and calamari - no comment 10/10 would get again. Brussel sprouts was nicely seasoned and crispy.

  via
• 

  Andre Durao 2 months ago

  5.0

  Best pizza I’ve ever had in New York! 🍕✨ The Salsiccia flavor was absolutely amazing — rich, full of taste, and perfectly balanced. If you love pizza, you have to try this one. Highly recommend!

  via
• 

  Jimmy Liang 7 months ago

  5.0

  What a treasure! This spot was such a great find for a pizza lover like me! Even though we were very impressed by the pizza here, their appetizers and main dishes were some of the best Italian dishes we’ve had. Coming back from Italy, the food is prepared with ingredients that tastes incredibly authentic and not at all heavy. Service was so warm and welcoming as well! A must try!

  via
• 

  Bob Trenton 4 months ago

  5.0

  Excellent restaurant, but tucked away location. All of the dishes our party had were aromatic and delicious. Nice interior decor, extremely clean throughout. At present they have an A rating with the health department, no doubt they have earned it. Customer service was friendly without being overbearing. The floor to ceiling windows brighten up a dreary winter day. Highly recommend if you’re in this part of Staten Island.

  via
• M

  mizid 4 months ago

  3.0

  Love Seppe and we go often. Not a big fan of their main dishes, but their appetizers (polenta fries, burrata) are delish and their pizzas are great. I like their drink menu too. We were there last night and everything was great until we ordered the affogato after a big meal. We got, what wasn’t even a full scoop, more like a spoon full, of ice cream and about 3 tablespoons of espresso. It wasn’t even a sufficient portion for one person, let alone two. For 12 bucks? I thought it was some kind of mistake. I told the waitress and she kind of just shrugged and apologized. We’ll go back at some point since we like the food but we won’t be ordering dessert again. Such a shame.

  via
• A

  apenasferraz 1 year ago

  5.0

  Seppe has one of the best pizza that I have ever ate! Great environment and staff. I had a great time with my friends. Tip: try the gambas and meatballs

  via
• 2

  290judeg 2 years ago

  1.0

  The restaurant had a terrible smell when I visited. I recommend against visiting for dinner. The waitress did not seem to mind.

  via
• F

  FLBfive 4 years ago

  5.0

  My experience was similar to the last reviewer. I had always heard great things about the establishment. What brought us here was my granddaughter's school (PS35) fundraiser. Ordered a salad, a soup and several pies. The dishes were great, and not something you could find elsewhere. Loved the crust on the pizzas. The family agreed that we look forward to returning and next time definitely ordering the deconstructed calzone that we didn't get to try. Happy to recommend this establishment to others!

  via
• B

  BarbaraBG62 4 years ago

  5.0

  Last night, I dined at Seppe's (for the first, but not the last, time) with my family. My granddaughter's school (PS35) had a fundraiser at the restaurant. The food is AMAZING! We had the calamari and deconstructed calzone for appetizers; the calzone was out of this world delicious. We then had the Fresca and Artie pies and just couldn't stop eating them! The staff were all friendly and I do appreciate the fact that the restaurant gave back to the school community with the fundraiser. We will most definitely be going back!

  via