Eleventh Street Pizza

Reviews

• 

  Sol B 8 months ago

  4.0

  Editing review: I knocked down one star since the last three times I’ve been here the pizza has been inconsistent. (I’ve been here numerous times!) We usually order two pizza and one is burnt and the other is okay. This went from being my favorite place to being a place I’m hesitant to eat at. See photos attached. I’ll give it two more tries before giving up completely. Original Review: I’m shocked this place only has 4.1 stars. I haven’t tried the Sicilian pizza (although pictured) but the NYC style is hands down the best pizza in Miami. And I’ve tried a lot of places. The ingredients are quality ingredients. The sourdough is delicious. This is my second time at Eleventh St and will continue coming. The prices are a bit high for a sit down hole in the wall restaurant, sure, I’ll give other reviewers that. It’s definitely not in a nice side of town and the place is whatever. I still like this place and for now will continue going and recommending it to others. I’ll update my review if anything changes.

  via
• S

  Sergio Licea 4 months ago

  5.0

  Wow, the pizza is so delicious and the staff is so friendly. I’m on a journey to find the top 10 New York style pizzas in Miami and this one ranks #1 so far!

  via
• 

  Kristan Bodden 2 months ago

  2.0

  Have been here 3xs over past year. 1st time was epic bc the pepperoni sicilian was just unreal so i ordered one of everything and most other stuff esp garlic knots was just overpriced meh. The 2nd time was abysmal with tons of thick nasty cheese and undercooked dough. The guy apologized after i said it was totally disgusting and said they had a new pizza guy. Offered to remake but i just wanted to puke so i left. Both times were the most expensive pizza experiences i'd had. Really very expensive for pizza even for miami where everything is priced at anomalously high price points. 3rd time? 1245pm today 6mos after my last terrible experience. Door locked but people eating inside. Girl comes to open door and says that they're closed bc she was there alone. She was very nice but this was the time I'd try to let them make up for the last time i was there. My take is as follows: 1) erratic food quality 2) the price point gives them no margin for error yet 2/3 of the time, they foul something up Try it if you like but the value proposition is way off bc off the outrageous price point and the swings in quality

  via
• 

  Vicki G. 6 months ago

  5.0

  And with my niece before a Heat game. What a fantastic little find in Dwntwn Miami!! Pizza by the slice, beer on tap, and great rock-n-roll tunes. They have pepperoni with hot honey that is absolutely delicious. Felt like I was at a neighborhood pizza joint in Jersey. A must try!!

  via
• 

  Justin Hoertling 3 months ago

  3.0

  Ordered the Brooklyn Cheese Sicilian for takeaway. I am not a pizza snob in any way but focaccia and cheese is pretty far from my expectation. Tasty but just not for me and well below in my opinion a decent simple traditional pizza (albeit maybe from outside of Florida, 1 year here and food consistently does not compare well to other cities in the US).

  via
• S

  Sergio Licea
  via
• K

  Kristan Bodden 4 months ago

  2.0

  Have been here 3xs over past year. 1st time was epic bc the pepperoni sicilian was just unreal so i ordered one of …

  via
• J

  Janesbestlife 1 year ago

  5.0

  Best pizza we've had in Miami! Thin crust sourdough pizza, super tasty. It's a small and cozy place. Imported wine and beer. Employees are energetic and attentive. Chocolate cookies to die for, come early because they disappear!

  via
• L

  LaVida 2 years ago

  5.0

  The pizza here is absolutely devine! Thin crust and neopolitan style. All you need is the cheese pizza. I've had it delivered twice, once using the restaurant's delivery. Once using Uber eats. The only downside is that it's pricey and I paid $40+ each time for one large pizza with delivery.

  via
• 6

  67enzab 3 years ago

  1.0

  I had lunch there today with my daughter and received the worst service. We were seated outside by the waiter who barely served us. I had to go inside the restaurant at least twice in order to get his attention. To top it off, the restaurant includes a 18% service charge (usually added for parties of six or more and we were a party of two) without any type of prior notice or statement in their menu (as required). I asked the server to remove the 18% service charge which he refused to do. So basically, he has no incentive to provide good service because he is automatically getting an 18% tip. So wrong. I asked for his name, but he refused to provide it. The receipt says it’s Lauren, but he said that was his managers name. As for the food, it is okay. Beware!

  via
• R

  rkaemp 4 years ago

  3.0

  I live nearby and decided to try the pizza. When I got there they had Philly cheesesteak on Saturday and Sunday so I decided to try it. The taste was good, but there was a lot of sinew in each bite of meat. The lady came up and asked me how I liked it and I told her it tasted great, but it was sinewy. She asked me if I would like to have a slice of pizza instead and I said yes. She refunded the steak sandwich. The pizza tasted good, but the crust was overcooked to my liking. When she came by to ask me how I liked it I just said it tastes good because I didn’t have the heart to complain about the crust. The customer service was excellent. The people were very friendly. I would go back based on how friendly and nice the lady was and give it a second try.

  via
• H

  highlandbeachflorida 5 years ago

  3.0

  Good tasting fresh made NY style large size pizza. Huge shareable pizzas with fresh quality toppings. Limited selection is the only downside. Ordered for pick up and our order of 3 pizzas was ready as promised.

  via